Very clever image, Jim. The composition feels unbalanced to my eye, and I'd trim from the right. It looks like he may have been preening from the smudge on the end of the bill. I'd clean that up, but to each his own. I do like this alot.
Thanks Grace. I did think about cleaning up the bill, but wasn't sure I wanted to tackle that task without my pen tablet at hand.
I'm sure most folks will agree with you on the crop from the right, but it comes out looking to square for me that way.
This is great! I wouldn't trim at all, I agree that I think it would be too square, plus too typical. The way you have this image framed makes it unique and I really like the out of focus foliage with just the bird in focus. Very nice and creative.
I think this is a lovely image and to be honest, I kind of like the original better than the crop. The image as presented has a feeling of looking in on a hiding bird, being allowed a special intamacy as it were. I think you lose that if you make the bird bigger and more " in your face". It is a strong bird in a gentle setting and very enjoyable.
Hi Jim, the heron is quite sharp and stands out nicely against the surroundings. To be honest, I think most of the top right corner is excessive and could be cropped out (maybe somewhere between your original and Todd's repost). I like how the habitat looks like middle lower half. I do like the "peeking through" feel though.
Thanks everyone. It is always interesting to read the different perspectives. What do you think about the idea of the space on the right being used for text as the intro to some sort of article?