
Originally Posted by
Robert Amoruso
Ken, constructively critiquing the image is not discouraged. I so no problem with Morkel asking Harshad why he felt the image did not work for him.
As you know, this site is about helping photographers better there image making skills and elaborating on what you like and dislike about an image and the reasons why is not discouraged.
What is discouraged is off-topic discussions, personalized snipping - whether related to the image or not, and other such similar non-community related discourse. And do not get me wrong, I am not saying you or anyone above did this, I am just clarifying your misunderstanding regarding debating/discussing a critique.
I feel the the discourse above was on-topic, informative and helpful in understanding our feelings on Morkel's image.