
Originally Posted by
Peter Hawrylyshyn
Arash
if you truly believe that edge selection, NR, sharpening options ... along or across a high contrast white border have no impact on the final image, you need to review basic post processing. I can't see why you won't accept this and instead keep insisting it's just the bird.
I never inferred a cause/explanation for Doug's photo - that's why i asked what post processing he did apply. If he applied none - then that's the best natural edge he could attain.
"The photo is natural and just the way it should be" - you forgot to add "according to me". I would hope at BPN whether it is perfect, a "cut and paste" look, a 3D look - members would still be allowed to express their individual opinions without rude replies, otherwise why bother posting a reply.
Bottom line:As i had already said - it is an excellent BIF image in the style Doug obviously prefers