Steve, Somewhere in between for me on the two. I do like the sharp details and exposure looks excellent. Pleasing BG and perch. I do wish for a slight head turn towards us but the inquisitive pose sure makes up for it. Lovely work.:)
I agree with Denise on both counts. If this is a female junco she's naturally a little lighter gray so I'd go halfway between the two as well. I also think a head turn would make this stronger but there's nothing wrong with it as is. He's really focused in on something, isn't he? Very nice details for such a small subject.
Thanks for viewing and the comments. Gus, before posting it I had adjusted it very similar to what you have, but felt it was too much. I agree it could use a bit more pop.