Saltmarsh Sparrow 2

[Bill Dix]

Got to Brigantine just after sunrise Friday morning, and one of the first birds I saw was this elusive little fellow. Managed to capture him without a lot of intrusive reeds and shadows this time, but he wouldn't let me get real close, thus the large crop. (Also see vert. version below) C&C appreciated.

D90 | 80-400 VR @ 400mm | ISO 640 | 1/2500s @ f/7.1 | -0.3 EV | HH

[Bill Dix]

Here's the same image in a vertical presentation. I think I like a little bit of habitat as in the OP, but curious how others feel.

[Joe Senzatimore]

I was going to suggest a vert. before I saw the post. Habitat articals are good , but I think too much OOF stuff distracts from this fine image. Stay with the Vertical,IMHO.

[denise ippolito]

I would like to ditto Joe. I like it as a vertical also and the oof stuff was a tiny bit distracting.Nice pose and perch.

[Daniel Cadieux]

The vertical has a much stronger composition, I love the branch tip poiting at the corner. The top one doesn't feature much habitat per say but rather OOF branches that don't add much IMO. Exposure and details look good.

[Greg Basco]

Bill, I like a hint of habitat but agree with the other that in this case the more simple, vertical presentation is more effective.

Cheers,
Greg Basco

[Myer Bornstein]

Bill,

The vertical wins hands down. A very strong image

[Bill Dix]

OK. Vertical it is. Thank you all for looking, and for the helpful feedback.

[Michael Zajac]

I like the vertical,Good sharpness and exposure.