I thought the same thing as Mark about the wings but at least they are both partially clipped - it looks more intentional that way! I like that the water in the FG is darker than the rest - it really pulls my eye to the birds and gives the image a strong anchor.
Appreciate the feedback as usual! Cropped this way on purpose. About the wing tips: in the original the left side wing tip was not clipped, though very close to the edge. The right side clipped a very small amount, easily fixed. This could easily be "repaired", which would then require additional space between them and the border. The problem is the more I spread the image out, the less impact of the subject. This was not my intent. If anything I might have cropped in closer (left and right).
Julie: the darker foreground was created for the exact purpose you sited: In ACR I used the gradient tool. Sometimes it improves an image, sometimes not.
Thank you Denise, Christopher, Julie, and Mark. regards~Bill