Good comp and pose, perfect HA. OK reflection. I wish the bill tip in the refelction wasn't broken off, and I would tone down the highlights on the bill.
I am with Daniel on the broken bill in the reflection, that really jumped out at me. Might be worth a trial of bill surgery to repair the reflection is you are so inclined.
Mital - very nice for all the reasons already mentioned. Can you tone down the white highlights on the bill? I also wonder about the broken bill in the reflection. Although a natural part of this image, it is a distraction.
Mital - nice soft light, head turn and detail as others have noted. I agree about the bill highlights and reflection. I might also consider removing the second catchlight, even though it comes naturally from the water reflection. A question of personal preference. Handsome image.
I like the broken beak as presented, after all, this is a reflection so one could never expect to have it 100% perfect. I also believe the shine on beak could go a bit darker.
Really awesome. Loved the head angle and the sharpness. With reflections, I prefer a little more room at the top of bird than the room below the reflection. But it might be a matter of taste.