Al,
Black Diamond Mercury Mitts are warm and have a separate slot inside the mitt for your index finger as well as thumb. You can feel the shutter quite well with this mitt design, but the outer shell is not waterproof. Typically, this is not a problem in very cold conditions. Manzella Cascade Mitts are made of windproof polar fleece and thinsulate, they are very warm. When purchasing a mitt I suggest getting at least one size larger size to accommodate a liner glove. Best to try before you buy. When staying out in extreme cold conditions I do as Jerry mentioned above, using the large very warm Outdoor Research Alti Mitten w/ lanyard and a thin wind-bloc/proof polar fleece glove inside.
Marmot’s Expedition mitts, are made for Mount Everest climbers and South Pole scientists. The downside is the liner lining is not attached directly to the mitt, making it slippery, gripping things is difficult, but they are very warm. No cold fingers in -30F, even with the wind cranking.
A participant in YNP had these glove-mitts
http://www.swanyamerica.com/cat.php?k=134468 You can open a watertight zipper and expose your inner gloved hand.
http://www.snowshack.com/detail/SNW+...tic+Mitt+Black
The 4-Piece Arctic Mitten Set protects hands down to -60° F in an environment where choosing anything but the best winter mittens means you lose your hands.
https://www.northernoutfitters.com/p...itten-set.aspx,
http://www.pr-inside.com/don-t-risk-...s-r1572590.htm
FYI- I got frostbite on two fingertips shooting in YNP -30 two years ago and those fingertips will forever be more prone to the cold because of the capillary damage.
Another staple for me is the Windbloc Headsokz.
Warmest Regards ;),
Chas