This was a throwaway image, a quick snap of my cousin's dog, Lulu, sitting in the back seat. Bright sunlit background outside, underexposed subject, just a mess. (Original is in a separate post below.) So I tried smudging it and adding a new background.
Nice job, like the background and the dog! The shading of the background is nice.
Looks like you cut a "very" little off the right ear, but had you not had the original it would not have been noticed, though I thought something about the ear was "wrong"? The other thing I also notice is a black spot in the area of the whiskers. You got the one below the eye, but I'm not sure if this one is a marking or dirt she picked up. Neither item is serious, but just to let you know.
You did a good job with a complex background.
Restoration is fun but oh so boring, at times, until you get the results you did here!:)
You even have the whiskers back in! Looks like a studio shot, and I really like what you have done with the smudge tool. I hope you write a book of Photoshop tips David, I would buy it!
Those sad loyal eyes! And I must say, a very good restoration job indeed. Yes it does look like a painting. I'd say...a very overall nice image. I would never have guess it was as the original was.