I agree he is goofy looking like this. I like the dappled light - especially in the BG.
I think John has a good point on the crop. On the bottom you are too close to the virtual legs - he can see them but they are there. On the back, you are cutting the virtual leg off.
I agree the composition could have been better. I was stalking this buck and he knew I was there, there were trees and ferns every where so every time I got anything like a view of him I grabbed a shot. It was pretty frustrating because he just wouldn't keep still.
Jon