Results 1 to 23 of 23

Thread: 5DS R versus 1DX II for Bosque 2016-17

  1. #1
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default 5DS R versus 1DX II for Bosque 2016-17

    Greetings,

    I own a 1DX and recently purchased a 600mm f/4 II, as I'm gearing up, literally, for the next migration season at the Bosque. Between now and then I'm going to buy and learn to use another camera body: the 1DX II or 5DS R. I'm looking for advice about which to buy next. Thanks.

  2. #2
    Super Moderator arash_hazeghi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    San Francisco, California, United States
    Posts
    18,553
    Threads
    1,320
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    What is missing from your 1DX that makes you want to buy a new camera?
    New! Sony Capture One Pro Guide 2022
    https://arihazeghiphotography.com/Gu.../Sony_C1P.html


    ------------------------------------------------
    Visit my blog
    http://www.arihazeghiphotography.com/blog

  3. #3
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Arash, thank you for taking the time to reply. And good question.

    I just came back from a practice shoot at the Rio Grande Nature Center State Park. And used the 2X TC to get reach across a pond. More focus points would have helped. I want the quicker focus acquisition I've read that the Mark II offers. I've read mixed reports about increased dynamic range and low light capabilities. If those are available, I'd like to take advantage of those as well.

    And, I want the latest and greatest.

    Best.

  4. #4
    Super Moderator arash_hazeghi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    San Francisco, California, United States
    Posts
    18,553
    Threads
    1,320
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Hi Jim,

    If you need to use a 600mm with a 2X TC most of the time then you have to rethink your strategy as you are shooting in a non-ideal location (birds way too far). I have a feeling that instead of a new camera you need instructions to improve your skills and field craft. Consider taking a workshop with someone skilled in this art. The gear you already own was the best available until a few months ago and certainly capable of making world-class images.

    The latest and greatest doesn't make you a better photographer unfortunately



    hope this helps
    New! Sony Capture One Pro Guide 2022
    https://arihazeghiphotography.com/Gu.../Sony_C1P.html


    ------------------------------------------------
    Visit my blog
    http://www.arihazeghiphotography.com/blog

  5. Thanks Ákos Lumnitzer thanked for this post
  6. #5
    Forum Participant
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,647
    Threads
    83
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    I'm with Arash on this one. You didn't mention anything that the 5DsR is better at. The better AF of the 1D X MkII is great, but it's not earth shattering. The 5DsR is wonderful for landscape, travel and portraits, but you don't seem to have any issues in that regard. Finding ways to get closer will probably improve your photography more than any additional piece of equipment.

  7. #6
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Thanks, Arash. I think David Salem knows someone in the Albuquerque area who might be a good teacher. My plan is to get whatever new gear I'm going to get, learn it and take instruction as the migratory birds begin to arrive in the fall. Meanwhile I'm shooting anything I can find. I was at the Bosque last weekend photographing grackles eating crayfish! And gear for its own sake is fun!

    Hi, David. Pixels. That's the big difference in the 1DX and 5DS R, of course. I've been following Artie's use of the 5DS R and like what it's doing for him. I plan to use it primarily for non-BIF shots. Yep. Getting closer is probably my biggest issue. And I think Arash's solution is likely the best: workshop(s). I'm eager to get back to southern California next spring and try to set up some days with David Salem to learn how to shoot raptors. I'm new to this. And yes, I have good gear, and my gear is much better than my skill. I'm willing to work on that.

    My gratitude to both of you.

  8. #7
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    An old man and his toys. I have it on good authority that I cannot take it with me. So thanks, fellows.

  9. #8
    Forum Participant
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,647
    Threads
    83
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Jim Keener View Post
    An old man and his toys. I have it on good authority that I cannot take it with me. So thanks, fellows.
    If you "must" buy something new, then the 5DsR is more different than what you already have. The pixels will be great for your non-BIF targets and the low fps will not be a big problem. Try it for landscape and travel, where it really shines.

  10. #9
    Publisher Arthur Morris's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Indian Lake Estates, FL
    Posts
    32,557
    Threads
    1,438
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by David Stephens View Post
    If you "must" buy something new, then the 5DsR is more different than what you already have. The pixels will be great for your non-BIF targets and the low fps will not be a big problem. Try it for landscape and travel, where it really shines.
    David, With all due respect, the 5DS R is a great camera body for birds and wildlife... There have been lots of examples on my blog and some here on BPN for at least about nine months. There will be a feature by skilled photographer Patrick Sparkman on the blog soon on why he prefers the 5DS R to the 1D X MARK II for birds. Arash will love it :)

    That said Arash's new 1D X Mark II peregrine stuff is beyond amazing.... Different strokes.

    a
    BIRDS AS ART Blog: great info and lessons, lots of images with our legendary BAA educational Captions; we will not sell you junk. 30+ years of long lens experience/e-mail with gear questions.

    BIRDS AS ART Online Store: we will not sell you junk. 35 years of long lens experience. Please e-mail with gear questions.

    Check out the new SONY e-Guide and videos that I did with Patrick Sparkman here. Ten percent discount for BPN members,

    E-mail me at samandmayasgrandpa@att.net.










  11. #10
    Publisher Arthur Morris's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Indian Lake Estates, FL
    Posts
    32,557
    Threads
    1,438
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by arash_hazeghi View Post
    Hi Jim,

    If you need to use a 600mm with a 2X TC most of the time then you have to rethink your strategy as you are shooting in a non-ideal location (birds way too far). I have a feeling that instead of a new camera you need instructions to improve your skills and field craft. Consider taking a workshop with someone skilled in this art. The gear you already own was the best available until a few months ago and certainly capable of making world-class images.

    The latest and greatest doesn't make you a better photographer unfortunately



    hope this helps
    Jim, You need to sign up for an IPT asap before you develop too many bad habits! See them all here: http://www.birdsasart.com/include-pages/ipt-updates/

    a
    BIRDS AS ART Blog: great info and lessons, lots of images with our legendary BAA educational Captions; we will not sell you junk. 30+ years of long lens experience/e-mail with gear questions.

    BIRDS AS ART Online Store: we will not sell you junk. 35 years of long lens experience. Please e-mail with gear questions.

    Check out the new SONY e-Guide and videos that I did with Patrick Sparkman here. Ten percent discount for BPN members,

    E-mail me at samandmayasgrandpa@att.net.










  12. #11
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Thanks, all.

  13. #12
    Forum Participant
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,647
    Threads
    83
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Arthur Morris View Post
    David, With all due respect, the 5DS R is a great camera body for birds and wildlife... There have been lots of examples on my blog and some here on BPN for at least about nine months. There will be a feature by skilled photographer Patrick Sparkman on the blog soon on why he prefers the 5DS R to the 1D X MARK II for birds. Arash will love it :)

    That said Arash's new 1D X Mark II peregrine stuff is beyond amazing.... Different strokes.

    a
    Are you saying that the 5DsR is not a great body for landscape and travel? I suggested that if money were burning a hole in his pocket, then this would be the one to buy. Still, buyer beware if planning to shoot BIF with it. It's slow fps is a big draw back for many of us ordinary shooters.

  14. #13
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by David Stephens View Post
    Are you saying that the 5DsR is not a great body for landscape and travel? I suggested that if money were burning a hole in his pocket, then this would be the one to buy. Still, buyer beware if planning to shoot BIF with it. It's slow fps is a big draw back for many of us ordinary shooters.
    David, I hadn't wanted to reply before to "must", but this seems a bit much. I appreciate your observations about the cameras. That's why I asked the question. Thank you. As for money and pockets, perhaps you wrote in haste. Best regards.

  15. #14
    Lifetime Member Doug Brown's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Albuquerque, NM
    Posts
    11,879
    Threads
    917
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Hi Jim. I think I'm the 'someone in the Albuquerque area who might be a good teacher.' I own both the 1Dx2 and the 1Dx. And I recently spent a week with the 5DS R. Also I'm quite familiar with the Bosque as I've led workshops there for years. The 1Dx is a very good camera (more than good enough for the Bosque IMO), but the 1Dx2 bests it in a number of areas. The new camera has significantly better low light AF, all focus points active at f/8, a higher frame rate, a much larger buffer, and focus points that stay illuminated during AF. The 1Dx2 also does a much better job with shadow detail. The pixel count is marginally higher and high ISO noise is slightly better. If you're looking to replace your 1Dx, the 1Dx2 is the camera I'd recommend (especially if you're planning on doing a lot of BIF photography). If you're looking to add a second camera body to your bag I'd go with the 5DS R; those extra pixels can really make a difference for you when you're photographing perched birds. But high ISO noise, a low frame rate, and huge RAW files are the 5DS R's Achilles heel. It's not nearly as versatile a camera as either the 1Dx or the 1Dx 2, but it makes a great second body.
    Upcoming Workshops: Bosque del Apache 2019, Ecuador 2020 (details coming soon)
    Website -
    Facebook - 500px

  16. #15
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Doug Brown View Post
    Hi Jim. I think I'm the 'someone in the Albuquerque area who might be a good teacher.'

    You are indeed. I have already signed up for the Bosque workshop with you and your two partners. Think I might have been the first. I'm looking forward to it very much. I sold a 1DX to a fellow who says he has gone on shoots with you. I won't print his name here without his permission, but he spoke very highly of you and the others. I think he went on a Costa Rica workshop.

    I'm going to do pretty much what you suggest: 1DX II as primary camera and the 5DS R as one of the backups. Lenses for birds: 600mm f/4 II for long reach and the 300mm f/2.8 II for intermediate work. Any other ideas?

    Thanks for checking in.

    Jim

  17. #16
    Forum Participant
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,647
    Threads
    83
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Jim Keener View Post
    You are indeed. I have already signed up for the Bosque workshop with you and your two partners. Think I might have been the first. I'm looking forward to it very much. I sold a 1DX to a fellow who says he has gone on shoots with you. I won't print his name here without his permission, but he spoke very highly of you and the others. I think he went on a Costa Rica workshop.

    I'm going to do pretty much what you suggest: 1DX II as primary camera and the 5DS R as one of the backups. Lenses for birds: 600mm f/4 II for long reach and the 300mm f/2.8 II for intermediate work. Any other ideas?

    Thanks for checking in.

    Jim
    Read Ari's review where he uses the sweet 400/f4 DO II with the 2.0x TC-III on the 1D X II before you decide on the shorter lens. That 400mm is one sweet lens and Ari reports that the AF is stunning on the 1DX2.

    As for my use of "must", I didn't mean it in an offensive way. I was attempting sarcasm about the disease many of us have, when money burns a hole in our pocket. Nothing wrong with that. Sorry if I offended.

  18. #17
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Thanks for the input about the 400 f/4 DO II, David. You certainly agree with the experts, and it is something I'm considering. I can get emotional about gear, and the 300 f/2.8 II is one of my dream lenses. Plus the extra stop of light might be important in making the photographs for which I'm buying a 300 or 400: the early morning at the crane ponds at the Bosque. There are some extraordinary images to be made there, I believe, and the lighting is difficult. Again, thanks for the thought.
    Last edited by Jim Keener; 06-28-2016 at 10:40 PM. Reason: To add David's name.

  19. #18
    Forum Participant
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,647
    Threads
    83
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Jim, with either the 1DX2 or the 5DsR, f/4 is going to be plenty, thanks to the good high-ISO performance of the 5D and the stunning high-ISO performance of the 1D. The 300 and 400 are both Series II, so you'll full AF benefit from the 1DX2 with either.

    I understand your attraction to the 300/2.8 II, as I had that same feeling, but then I shot with the new 400 f/4 DO II and was blown away. Teamed with the 1D X2, it's pretty much the ideal BIF lens, IMO, based on my limited shooting with lesser bodies and Ari's testimony with the EF 2.0x TC-III. I shoot my big white hand held and going to this neat little lens, with stunning IQ, it seems like a feather. Oh, and 33% more reach over the 300mm is a very important consideration for BIF.

  20. #19
    Lifetime Member Doug Brown's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Albuquerque, NM
    Posts
    11,879
    Threads
    917
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Of course you could always wait for the rumored 600 f/4 DO!!!
    Upcoming Workshops: Bosque del Apache 2019, Ecuador 2020 (details coming soon)
    Website -
    Facebook - 500px

  21. #20
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    David, you make a great case.

    Doug, I'm 72. Wait?

  22. #21
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by David Stephens View Post
    Jim, with either the 1DX2 or the 5DsR, f/4 is going to be plenty, thanks to the good high-ISO performance of the 5D and the stunning high-ISO performance of the 1D. The 300 and 400 are both Series II, so you'll full AF benefit from the 1DX2 with either.

    I understand your attraction to the 300/2.8 II, as I had that same feeling, but then I shot with the new 400 f/4 DO II and was blown away. Teamed with the 1D X2, it's pretty much the ideal BIF lens, IMO, based on my limited shooting with lesser bodies and Ari's testimony with the EF 2.0x TC-III. I shoot my big white hand held and going to this neat little lens, with stunning IQ, it seems like a feather. Oh, and 33% more reach over the 300mm is a very important consideration for BIF.
    Know what? I think you're correct. I'm borrowing the 400 DO from Canon next week. Thanks for staying with me regarding this.

  23. #22
    Publisher Arthur Morris's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Indian Lake Estates, FL
    Posts
    32,557
    Threads
    1,438
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by David Stephens View Post
    Oh, and 33% more reach over the 300mm is a very important consideration for BIF.
    Don't forget that 33% more reach means that the subject with the 400 will be 1.77 times larger with a 400mm than with the 300mm. Why? The area of the subject is a function of the square of the focal length. As you well know, Jim, I am selling my 300 II and going with the 400 DO II. As early as the original The Art of Bird Photography I wrote, "Always choose a longer slower lens for bird photography over a faster shorter one..."
    BIRDS AS ART Blog: great info and lessons, lots of images with our legendary BAA educational Captions; we will not sell you junk. 30+ years of long lens experience/e-mail with gear questions.

    BIRDS AS ART Online Store: we will not sell you junk. 35 years of long lens experience. Please e-mail with gear questions.

    Check out the new SONY e-Guide and videos that I did with Patrick Sparkman here. Ten percent discount for BPN members,

    E-mail me at samandmayasgrandpa@att.net.










  24. Thanks David Stephens thanked for this post
  25. #23
    BPN Member Jim Keener's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Idyllwild, California
    Posts
    499
    Threads
    59
    Thank You Posts

    Default

    Well, the best minds agree. I'm highly likely to purchase the lens soon.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Web Analytics