-
BPN Member
-
Hi Anette,
I keep looking at this and am not quite sure what to make of it. I love the beautiful light, it is just superb but I'm not sure about the composition's strength. I'm not sure what I'd do differently or whether to treat it just as an abstract body part and enjoy the warm colours for what they are. Not very helpful I'm afraid so hope that someone else can give a bit more help.
-
BPN Member
Hi Anette,
i am sorry to say this is not grabbing me, i am like Hillary some kind of no idea what to do with it to make it look better from my POV.
The thing that grabs me is the beautiful lightning and the rim lights,but there are some issues for me like the horizon through the fluke, the detail that is somehow visible and somehow not enough…….!The comp mmmmhhhhh!?!
The only thing that could work for me is a silhouette or kind of ………maybe.
Just being honest
TFS Andreas
-
BPN Member
Hi Hilary and Andreas,
thank you very much for your honest comments, always appreciate those very much, that s what I want. For the comp, I was before posting well aware that many do not like the comp at all and that it does not give you , here in the forum, the wow and great effect. It does not need to be always a wow or great effect to have for me, that is me. Feel free to crop in any way you might think. It is FF
As well for the mods, you can delete if you like :))
I will be gone till tomorrow eve. My next reply has to wait till Monday!
Thank you very much
have a great weekend
ciao Anette
-
Lifetime Member
Hi Anette - I've looked a couple of times as well. I like the idea and that you continue to experiment. The warm light is great but I kept thinking you needed a bit stronger rim light and a darker silhouette. However, the problem with a darker silhouette is that you lose the fact that it is 2 flippers and the silhouette looks funny because it's 2. So I think your choice to show some detail is a good one. So this is my long way of saying I think you needed more cooperative walruses so that there was only one flipper raised. I agree with Andreas about the horizon intersecting the flipper but doubt that you could have gotten lower to raise the flipper above the horizon.
Have a great weekend and TFS,
Rachel
-
Post a Thank You. - 1 Thanks
-
BPN Member
THanks Rachel ------ flukes for whales and flippers for all seals or relatives,right, dumb german.
-
Post a Thank You. - 1 Thanks
-
Hi Anette
Nice to try something new … but often they do not work out .. sorry the composition is just not strong enough .
-
Post a Thank You. - 1 Thanks
-
Wildlife Moderator
Hi Anette, I like the warm tones & colours on this and great to see an alternative POV.
I don't have an issue about the horizon as it's quite subtle, allow if you were lower looking more up it may resolve this however create, more, or bigger issues. I don't think even putting the flipper more to the left could help. There is some more detail you can, if you wish extract from the main flipper/fin.
TFS
Steve
PS I would look to 'knocking back' the opacity in your © it's a little dominating, thanks.
Post Production: It’s ALL about what you do with the tools and not, which brand of tool you use.

-
Post a Thank You. - 1 Thanks
-
BPN Member
Thank you very much everybody for your time to comment. I highly appreciate it.
Steve, I was already flat on the ground, was no way to get deeper. I used my camera bag as tripod, or better said as a bean bag. Worked out well.
Will keep it in mind with my watermark and opacity.
Thanks a gin
Have a great Sunday eve
Ciao
Anette
-
Wildlife Moderator
Yes please, are you buying?
Post Production: It’s ALL about what you do with the tools and not, which brand of tool you use.

-
BPN Member
-
BPN Member
and if the above is wrong again, than I blame it on all food I had to eat the last couple of days on the Birthdays parties ( 2 of those ) and my 3 hour drive back home. 180-200km on German Highway YEAH, with a few interruptions. Than the slow poke highways of Swissyland with 120km, yawn