Grady Weed
05-03-2009, 12:05 PM
First, I would like to thank BPN's publishers for allowing me to take part in this judging process for theme week. I spoke to Denise by phone. She was very excited and shows a lot of enthusiasm for this forum. Her constant participation and encouraging comments, I believe, are the driving force for this forum's unique perspective.
Before I joined BPN, I was mostly a traditional, Ansel Adams-type of photographer. I love black and white and landscapes. My love for avian and wildlife grew as time went by. Participating in Out of the Box has sparked a new interest. Therefore, I looked for several things: the very first was visual impact. Often my initial impression is something that does not change when I see a photograph. So I can usually trust what I first see and then feel. Secondly, I looked for at least somewhat believability. Was there some element of truth but just stretched? Did the image make me laugh yet not laugh AT the image? And last, I looked at Photoshop Skills. I must say, I am not a huge fan of extreme manipulation. A photograph should be able to stand on its own as it is before being manipulated. If a person takes a blown image or one that is no good in the first place and then just covers it over with a few photoshop techniques, I do not consider that a worthwhile image. I did not see those types of images here during this week's contest.
This week's winners are..
First Place: Psycho Kitty by Kerry Perkins
Second Place: Alien Cows by Harold Davis
Third Place: Critters (tree frog) by Jackie Schuknecht
Honorable Mention:
From the Night by Mark Fuge. I want to say, Mark, that image was rather nice. Being a native of Florida myself for almost 25 years I love Florida wildlife. Often gators are imaged in a traditional mirror water finish, which is nice, but not many have been made like your presentation. That kind of creativity is to be applauded.
I know that moderators and publishers were not eligible, but I do feel several are worth mentioning: First, Alfred Forns with his grasshopper in the spotlight. That picture was magnificently created. The very first thing I thought of was the movie "A Bug's Life" and Mos Eisley's cantina in Star Wars. It created an instant connection between the viewer and the image.
Purple People Eater by Doug Brown was another eye catcher. All he did was change the color and an instant hit was made. Who doesn't know the song "Purple People Eater"? And then Denise Ippolito's Tiger Kitty Under the Glass. It made me laugh, and it was almost believable.
In conclusion, I would like to encourage everyone on BPN to come up with something to contribute to this forum. Break out of the box, do something different, and grow your artistic vision.
Before I joined BPN, I was mostly a traditional, Ansel Adams-type of photographer. I love black and white and landscapes. My love for avian and wildlife grew as time went by. Participating in Out of the Box has sparked a new interest. Therefore, I looked for several things: the very first was visual impact. Often my initial impression is something that does not change when I see a photograph. So I can usually trust what I first see and then feel. Secondly, I looked for at least somewhat believability. Was there some element of truth but just stretched? Did the image make me laugh yet not laugh AT the image? And last, I looked at Photoshop Skills. I must say, I am not a huge fan of extreme manipulation. A photograph should be able to stand on its own as it is before being manipulated. If a person takes a blown image or one that is no good in the first place and then just covers it over with a few photoshop techniques, I do not consider that a worthwhile image. I did not see those types of images here during this week's contest.
This week's winners are..
First Place: Psycho Kitty by Kerry Perkins
Second Place: Alien Cows by Harold Davis
Third Place: Critters (tree frog) by Jackie Schuknecht
Honorable Mention:
From the Night by Mark Fuge. I want to say, Mark, that image was rather nice. Being a native of Florida myself for almost 25 years I love Florida wildlife. Often gators are imaged in a traditional mirror water finish, which is nice, but not many have been made like your presentation. That kind of creativity is to be applauded.
I know that moderators and publishers were not eligible, but I do feel several are worth mentioning: First, Alfred Forns with his grasshopper in the spotlight. That picture was magnificently created. The very first thing I thought of was the movie "A Bug's Life" and Mos Eisley's cantina in Star Wars. It created an instant connection between the viewer and the image.
Purple People Eater by Doug Brown was another eye catcher. All he did was change the color and an instant hit was made. Who doesn't know the song "Purple People Eater"? And then Denise Ippolito's Tiger Kitty Under the Glass. It made me laugh, and it was almost believable.
In conclusion, I would like to encourage everyone on BPN to come up with something to contribute to this forum. Break out of the box, do something different, and grow your artistic vision.